The trophy is the consolation (tertiary) event for the teams at the Autumn Congress. It ended in 2022 after the congress was discontinued.
Last updated 7th December 2023
| Year | Players |
| 1950 | Miss J Curry, Mrs J Smith, C Hunt, Mrs A Alfandry |
| 1951 | Miss Younghughes, FS Thurner, Mrs Erskine, Mrs Palmer |
| 1952 | Not held |
| 1953 | Not held |
| 1954 | D Carter, RJ Blyton, AD Neale, AD Peck |
| 1955 | J Giddins, Mrs J Giddins, Mrs Pearson, JE Hawkins |
| 1956 | Not known |
| 1957 | Not known |
| 1958 | P Coleman, Mrs P Coleman, Sir Patrick McMahon, H Pepper |
| 1959 | Mrs V Cooper, Harry St John Ingram, Pip Dellaporta, Freddie Dellaporta |
| 1960 | Major Geoffrey Fell, Rita Oldroyd, Joe Pearlstone, Mrs P Alberquerque |
| 1961 | Not known |
| 1962 | Phyllis Williams, John Langiert, Joe Pearlstone, Bobby Franses |
| 1963 | John Collings, Jonathan Cansino, MD Penn, Carl Hille |
| 1964 | Mrs Clegg, Mrs Allen, Mrs Fransey, Mrs Shaw |
| 1965 | Not known |
| 1966 | Paul Hayes, Lynn Hayes, Stuart Staveley, Anne Staveley |
| 1967 | Mrs C Harris, GP Hirst, Raymond Brock, Irving Gordon |
| 1968 | E Seldon, JS Callaway, RL Poulter, Mrs HE Humble |
| 1969 | Not known |
| 1970 | Not known |
| 1971 | Not known |
| 1972 | GH Birch, Tom Bradley, GWR Cowpland, RL Poulter |
| 1973 | Not known |
| 1974 | Not known |
| 1975 | SNJ Murphy, Steve Preston, Mike Walsh, Rob Sharpe |
| 1976 | David Gostyn, Keith Loveys, John Reardon, Andrew Thompson |
| 1977 | Jack Nunes, John Sadler, Douglas Smerdon, Tony Waterlow |
| 1978 | Patrick Jourdain, Robert Upton, Mike Hirst, Patrick Shields |
| 1979 | Elaine Pencharz, Lynne Hayes, Bill Pencharz, Mike Tedd |
| 1980 | Pete Jackson, Steve Lodge, David Kendrick, David Burn |
| 1981 | David Carlisle, Ian Gardiner, Fiske Warren, Andrew Macalistair |
| 1982 | Stan Ritter, Keith Manley, Mrs I Sheril A. Sheril |
| 1983 | Joe Halmai, Richard Palmer, Peter Simon, Joe Moskal |
| 1984 | Ralph Smith, Michael Cashman, C Smith, Nick Perceval-Price |
| 1985 | Brian Callaghan, Christine Duckworth, Phil Bailey, John Probst |
| 1986 | David Muller, Geoff Hiller, Brian Callaghan, Rob Cliffe |
| 1987 | Maureen Dennison, Phil Thornton, Fiona Brickwood, Kevin Elstow |
| 1988 | Graham Hedley, Berry Hedley, Mrs J Gower, G Reynolds |
| 1989 | D Vasey, P Vasey, John Dakin, John Moore |
| 1990 | Miles Cowling, Ann Sharples, GM Pick, PP Chew |
| 1991 | Tony Gordon, Roger Jackson, Andrew Thompson, David Maeer |
| 1992 | Geoff Cronin, Malcolm Pryor, Martin Hoffman, Phil Karani |
| 1993 | M Short, C Cheek, David Muller, Trevor Mathews |
| 1994 | Phil Karani, Jorg Dombrowe, Martin Hoffman, John Elliott |
| 1995 | Danny Roth, Cecil Leighton, Maurice Leighton, Maureen Dennison |
| 1996 | Event abandoned because of a power cut |
| 1997 | Tim Rees, Andrew MacNair, Peter Lindon, Dee Lindon |
| 1998 | David Martin, Brian Senior, Gordon Rainsford, Glen Holman |
| 1999 | Richard Currie, John Hemington, Wendy Miller, Jane Morton, |
| 2000 | David Martin, John Carter, Frank Pratt, Daphne Philipps |
| 2001 | Sandy Smith, Martin Smith, Peter Rowlands, Mary Hart |
| 2002 | Jack Mizel, Andrew McIntosh, Alexander Allfrey, David Bakhshi |
| 2003 | Mike Fletcher. Richard Harris,Brian Ransley, Peter Nicholls |
| 2004 | Geoffrey Wolfarth, Roz Wolfarth, Brian Senior, Nevena Senior |
| 2005 | John Armstrong, David Stevenson, Rob Cliffe, Nora Smith |
| 2006 | Phil Norman, Jo Norman, Chris Bradley, Guy Lawrenson |
| 2007 | David Wing, Barbara Cohen, Irene Fine, Nigel Clayton |
| 2008 | Ken Ford, Ian Swanson, Denis O’Donovan, John Short |
| 2009 | Eddi Lucioni, Miles Cowling, Alan Woo, Olivia Woo |
| 2010 | Darren Evetts, Margaret Wort, Myra Twyman, Roger Twyman |
| 2011 | Angela Abbott, James Spencer, Paul Gibbons, Sharon Bayne |
| 2012 | Kath Stynes, Millie Jones, Rob Cliffe, David Burn |
| 2013 | Trevor Thrower, Jim Deacon, Robert Miller, Marcus Witt |
| 2014 | Tom Paske, Catherine Seale, David Gold, Susanna Gross |
| 2015 | Christopher Whitehouse, Mary-Ann Sheehy, Alexander Lishkov, C Rowland |
| 2016 | David Bakhshi, Jasmine Bakhshi, Liz Gahan, Liam Sanderson |
| 2017 | Sandra Nicholson, Krys Kazmierczak, R Todd, L Furnival |
| 2018 | David Gold, Catherine Seale, Tom Paske, B Tiller |
| 2019 | Trupti Shah, John Prust, Naomi Gibbs, Mike Rawlins |
| 2020 | Nigel Wolfendale, Dick Davey, Bob Holder, David Owen |
| 2021 | Fiona Brown, Helen Erichsen, Ollie Burgess, Diana Nettleton |
| 2022 | Lilias Lamont, Andrew Doye, James Bond, Graham Davison |