Wrong description of partner's call
The following hand came up at a game today:
East dealer. None vul.
The bidding went:
W N E S
- - P P
1NT 2H* P 2S
P 3C P P
*Alerted as hearts and spades.
When the dummy came down the TD was called.
There are three possible adjustments:
2S making 3 to E/W
4S down at least 2 if not 3 to N/S
5C down 2 to N/S
A number of good players whose views were sought said that no way they as south would pass partner's 3C bid, they would either go on to S or C.
What does this group think?